Paying college football players could reverse trend of bowl game opt-outs, boost non-CFP postseason

Thu, May 2, 2024

Paying college football players could reverse trend of bowl game opt-outs, boost non-CFP postseason

SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. (AP) - With the expanded College Football Playoff locked in through 2031, questions still remain about what the rest of the postseason will look like.

One thing is certain, there will still be bowls.

"College football cannot have a postseason that only provides 12 opportunities," Nick Carparelli, executive director of Bowl Season, the organization that advocates for bowl games, said Thursday. "That's contrary to every other NCAA sport. And the leadership of college athletics has been very clear in recent years that they want more opportunities for student athletes to compete in the postseason, not less across all sports."

Carparelli has some ideas to keep bowl games robust and relevant, including creating more freedom for games to make the most interesting matchups. Though the biggest change could come from outside the bowl system as college football moves to a more professionalized model and player compensation agreements mandate postseason participation.

The CFP expands from four to 12 teams this season. It could jump to 14 teams starting as soon as 2026. Even in a four-team system, the playoff decreased the focus on the bowls and prompted discussion about how meaningful they were.

READ MORE Wisconsin tries to regain supremacy in the trenches under its 4th O-line coach in as many years Say hello (again) to EA Sports College Football. The beloved video-game behemoth is back Deion Sanders, son respond to social media criticisms over how coach handled transfers at Colorado

While the dozens of bowl games played around Christmas and New Year's still draw a healthy amount of eyeballs to TVs, player opt-outs have become commonplace.

"I still believe at their core kids like playing football," said Carparelli, who was attending a Fiesta Bowl event that included Big 12 and Mountain West Conference meetings earlier this week. "They've been presented with reasons why not to in recent years. And I think that's very unfortunate for sure."

Caparelli believes the future of college football includes revenue sharing with players and possibly name, image and likeness compensation deals that set terms similar to pro sports contracts.

"As player compensation becomes the norm, at some point in time, I think it's reasonable to expect that there's going to be some obligation on the part of the student-athlete receiving the compensation to perform the duties as assigned," he said. ""In my mind, 12 regular-season games, a bowl game or playoff."

This year there will be 36 bowl games played outside the College Football Playoff, which will also include four first-round games played on campus sites.

Carparelli said he doesn't believe the bowl eligibility minimum of six victories will change. Whether there will still be a need for three dozen bowl games for the 2026 season and beyond is to be determined.

Even the bowls outside the playoff structure have contractual agreements with conferences that run concurrent to the CFP's original 12-year deal, which expires after the 2025 season. All those games are about to become free agents.

Conferences prefer to lock in numerous bowl partnerships to guarantee eligible teams a spot in the postseason.

Carparelli would like to encourage more flexibility in the bowl selection process, allowing the games the ability to make compelling matchups with the available teams - more similar to way bowls operated 30 or 40 years ago - instead of being locked into predetermined conference deals.

"It would be the conferences that would need to make that decision," he said. "Anything is possible. At the highest level, the CFP has decided that there's not going to be any certainty there outside of five conference champions to be in that system. I don't see any reason why that can't translate to the next level of bowl games."


Follow Ralph D. Russo at and listen at


AP college football:

RALPH D. RUSSO Russo has been the national college football writer for The Associated Press for two decades. He is a native New Yorker. twitter mailto "
Article Copyright © 2024 The Associated Press, All Rights Reserved.